Dialpad and Five9 AI-agent comparisons should include the people who handle exceptions. Automating routine questions can change the work arriving at the contact centre, but it does not remove the need for staffing, ownership and clear routing when a request needs a person.
Compare the intended product deployment
Dialpad’s enterprise conversational AI page describes agent-to-human handoffs into its contact-centre environment and distinguishes its native agents from a Google virtual-agent integration. Five9’s AI Agents page describes automated interactions and human handoffs. Confirm which exact product and channel the proposed implementation includes.
Ask each vendor to demonstrate the same three requests: a routine answer, a task requiring a connected system and a question requiring human authority. A broad platform presentation does not establish which of those paths is ready in the quoted configuration.
Review what the human receives
Five9’s contextual handoff explanation describes passing conversation history, intent and account context. Treat that as a capability to verify in the implementation, not evidence that every field your staff needs will automatically appear.
| Handoff detail | Question for the demonstration |
|---|---|
| Customer identity | Which record was matched and how? |
| Attempted action | What has already been checked or changed? |
| Unresolved issue | What decision does the person need to make? |
| Customer promise | What did the AI say would happen next? |
Model the remaining workload
In an illustrative day with 500 incoming requests, suppose the trial routes 150 to people. That figure alone does not determine staffing. The remaining requests may be longer or more complex than the original average. Measure their arrival pattern and handling time before changing schedules.
Include abandoned transfers and repeat calls in the review. A call that exits automation is not necessarily resolved. Equally, a short conversation with an accurate answer can be useful even when no additional workflow action is required.
Test the unavailable-team case
Ask for a specialist when the intended queue has no available representative. Inspect the customer message, queue behaviour and follow-up record. Confirm who owns the request after the caller leaves. This exposes staffing and process gaps that a fully staffed sales demonstration may hide.
Evaluate a completed service journey
Compare resolution, repeat contact, staff rework and the cost of operating the configured system. Save the scope, integration requirements and unresolved questions beside the quote. There is no universal staffing reduction or conversion improvement established by either platform description; gather evidence from your own representative workload.
Staffing Design Before You Commit to a Configuration
A meaningful comparison of AI-agent platforms begins well before a contract is signed, and the most consequential decisions concern the people who will work alongside the automation rather than the software itself. Many evaluation processes focus on what the AI can handle autonomously and overlook a separate, equally important question: what does the workload look like for the staff who receive what the AI cannot finish? Answering that question requires deliberate design work, not assumptions drawn from vendor demonstrations conducted under ideal conditions.
Start by mapping every contact type your operation currently handles, including its frequency, its average handling time, its resolution path and the authority level required to close it. This baseline serves two purposes. First, it gives you a realistic view of which requests are genuine candidates for automation and which carry complexity, sensitivity or regulatory weight that requires a person throughout. Second, it gives you a reference point against which to measure what changes after a system goes live. Without that reference, improvement claims remain unverifiable, and staffing decisions rest on guesswork.
Once the contact inventory exists, assign each type a provisional routing category. A useful working taxonomy might distinguish self-service completions, assisted completions where the AI drafts but a person approves, warm transfers where context travels with the customer, cold queues where the customer must re-explain, and escalations that require specialist authority. The categories matter because each places a different demand on staff time, skill and scheduling. An operation that treats all non-automated contacts as equivalent will consistently misforecast the work arriving at human queues.
Worked Scenario: A Billing Dispute Through the Full Journey
Consider a fictional customer, referred to here as the account holder, who contacts a subscription business about a charge they do not recognise. The scenario illustrates decision points that any AI-agent configuration must address, regardless of which platform is under evaluation.
The account holder opens a chat session. An AI agent greets them, collects the account reference and asks what brought them in. The account holder describes the charge. The AI searches transaction records and identifies a renewal line item. It presents that information and asks whether the account holder would like a receipt. The account holder says they want a refund.
At this point, the AI agent faces a branch. Issuing a refund may require verifying whether a refund policy condition is met, accessing a payment gateway, logging a reason code and updating the account status. Each of those steps may or may not sit within the AI agent's configured permissions. If any step falls outside its authority, the conversation must move to a person.
The transfer moment is where evaluation evidence matters most. When the billing agent receives the conversation, what exactly arrives? A well-designed handoff should tell the agent which account was authenticated, what the customer said, what the AI already checked, what it found, what the customer was told and what decision now requires human authority. If the agent receives only a transcript, they must re-read it, re-verify identity, re-establish rapport and potentially re-explain a wait. That re-work is measurable, and during an evaluation it should be timed and recorded.
The agent reviews the account, confirms the renewal was correctly charged but determines that a goodwill refund is within policy given the account holder's tenure. They approve and process it. They tell the account holder what will happen and in what timeframe. They log the outcome.
Now examine what happens at the seams. Did the AI's handoff record update when the agent took action? If the account holder calls back the following day, does the next AI agent see that the matter is closed? If the agent was unavailable at transfer, where did the conversation go, and who is responsible for following up? These are not hypothetical edge cases; they are routine operating conditions that a stable deployment must handle predictably.
Criteria for Comparing Handoff Quality Across Platforms
When you observe handoff behaviour during a structured demonstration, several criteria carry meaningful weight. The reasons they matter are practical rather than technical.
Identity continuity. The agent should be able to confirm who they are speaking with without asking the customer to repeat information already given. If re-verification is required for security reasons, that step should be flagged explicitly rather than left to the agent to improvise. Evaluate whether the handoff record distinguishes verified identity from inferred identity, because an agent acting on inferred identity carries a different risk than one acting on confirmed identity.
Action history. The agent should see what the AI attempted, not just what the customer said. If the AI tried to retrieve a record and failed, that failure is relevant context. If it successfully applied a discount code, the agent should not offer another. Without action history, agents duplicate effort or contradict the automated interaction, both of which damage the customer experience.
Outstanding obligation. If the AI told the customer that a person would call them back within a stated window, that promise must be visible to whoever handles the follow-up. Ask the demonstrating vendor to show how a customer-facing commitment made by the AI surfaces in the agent's workspace. If it does not surface automatically, ask how the business would track it manually and what that process would cost in coordinator time.
Reason for transfer. The agent should know why they received this conversation, not just that they received it. A transfer flagged as policy exception is handled differently from one flagged as technical failure or customer distress. Evaluate whether the reason code is generated by the AI, by a rule, or not at all.
Queue visibility. During a transfer, the agent should be able to see the customer's wait time and position. During an evaluation, observe whether the agent has to ask the customer how long they have been waiting. That question is a signal that wait-state information is not reaching the human interface.
Exception Cases That Reveal System Limits
Routine demonstrations show the system performing at its best. Structured exception testing shows how it behaves under the conditions your staff will encounter regularly.
Test a customer who gives ambiguous or contradictory information. A common illustrative case: the account holder gives a name that matches the account but an email address that does not. Ask how the AI handles the discrepancy. Does it escalate, ask clarifying questions, log the inconsistency, or proceed on the matched field? Each choice has an implication for fraud risk and for the work arriving at the human queue. Human agents should retain responsibility for decisions made in ambiguous identity situations; the question here is whether the system surfaces the ambiguity clearly or obscures it.
Test a request that spans two departments. A customer wants to change their delivery address and dispute an invoice. The address change may belong to one team and the dispute to another. Observe whether the AI handles the compound request or resolves only the first part. If only the first part is resolved and the customer is transferred, does the transfer include both topics, or does the second topic require the customer to re-initiate?
Test a request submitted outside staffed hours. The AI accepts the conversation, collects details, but no agent is available. What does the customer receive? What record is created? Who reviews that record the next morning, by what process, and how is the response prioritised alongside live inbound work? If the answer is that a supervisor checks a queue report, ask to see that report and evaluate whether it contains enough information to act without re-contacting the customer.
Test a sentiment shift mid-conversation. The customer begins calmly and becomes frustrated after receiving an automated response they find unhelpful. Observe whether the system detects the shift and how it responds. Human escalation triggered by tone is a reasonable design choice, but the criteria for triggering it, and the skill level of the receiving agent, both affect whether the escalation resolves the frustration or compounds it.
Acceptance Exercise: Conditions That Indicate a Configuration Is Ready
Before signing off on a go-live, consider structuring an acceptance exercise around observable outcomes rather than feature checklists. The following conditions give you concrete evidence to evaluate; they are framed as questions your team can answer by watching the system operate on representative test cases.
Can a new agent, with no prior knowledge of a test conversation, read the handoff record and state accurately what the customer wants, what has already been tried and what decision they need to make? Run this with at least two agents independently. If their summaries diverge substantially from each other or from the actual conversation, the handoff record is not carrying enough information.
Can a supervisor identify, within a reasonable review period, every conversation that transferred to a human in the past shift, the reason for each transfer and whether each was subsequently resolved? If finding that information requires querying multiple systems or asking individual agents, the reporting structure needs attention before volume scales.
When the system routes a conversation to an unavailable queue, does a responsible owner receive a notification with enough detail to follow up without re-reading a full transcript? Define what that notification must contain, then check whether the proposed configuration produces it.
After a full day of test operation, can the quality lead identify any conversation in which a customer received conflicting information from the AI and from a human agent? If yes, trace the source of the conflict. If no, consider whether the test day included enough variety in customer requests to surface that risk, or whether the test scope was too narrow to be conclusive.
Handover Arrangements for Ongoing Operations
A go-live is not the end of the evaluation; it is the beginning of an operational cycle that needs defined ownership. Assign explicit accountability for each of the following areas before the system handles live customer contacts.
Conversation quality review should sit with a named role, not a team in aggregate. That person or function should have access to both the AI-handled conversations and the human-handled conversations to evaluate them against the same resolution criteria. Reviewing only one stream obscures the full picture of customer experience.
Routing rule changes should follow a change-management process, however lightweight. An informal adjustment to a routing threshold can shift significant volume between AI and human queues without any corresponding change to staffing levels. Documenting the change, the reason and the expected impact creates an audit trail for the next staffing review.
Agent feedback on handoff quality should be collected regularly and reviewed against the acceptance criteria established before go-live. If agents consistently report that they receive insufficient context, that feedback should trigger a structured review of the handoff record rather than an informal workaround. Workarounds accumulate and eventually become invisible to anyone not doing the front-line work.
System behaviour during peak periods should be reviewed separately from average-load behaviour. Queue depths, transfer rates and handling times may all change meaningfully under load, and the staffing model built on average conditions may not hold under those circumstances. Schedule a deliberate peak-period review before treating the steady-state model as reliable.
Choosing between AI-agent platforms is ultimately a decision about how your operation will work rather than about which software has the longer feature list. The questions that change a purchase decision are the ones answered by watching the system handle your specific contact types, your specific exception cases and your specific staff constraints. An evaluation built around those questions gives you evidence; an evaluation built around a vendor's prepared demonstration gives you a best-case scenario. Use both, and weight the former more heavily when the two diverge.
Constructing a Side-by-Side Decision Record During Live Evaluation
When two platforms are under active evaluation simultaneously, the natural temptation is to run separate demonstrations on separate days and compare impressions afterward. That approach introduces memory bias and makes it difficult to attribute specific observations to specific configurations. A more rigorous method is to build a shared decision record during each session, using the same test cases in the same sequence, so that every observation occupies a comparable row in a structured log rather than a narrative paragraph written after the fact.
The decision record differs from a feature checklist. A feature checklist asks whether a capability exists; a decision record asks what the capability produced when it was used. The distinction matters because a capability that exists but produces unreliable output, or that requires significant configuration before it works in your context, is not equivalent to one that produces consistent output in its current state. During evaluation, record what you observed, the conditions under which you observed it and any caveat the demonstrating team offered. Caveats are informative; they tell you what the vendor considers a configuration task versus a ready behaviour.
A useful decision record for this comparison might be organised around the three request types mentioned in the existing material: the routine answer, the task requiring a connected system and the question requiring human authority. For each type, record the platform response, the handoff content, the agent action required and the time elapsed between transfer initiation and agent readiness. Those four fields create a consistent basis for side-by-side reading without requiring the evaluator to remember what happened across sessions.
Include a column for open questions that arose during the session. A demonstrating team may answer a question partially or defer it to a follow-up call. Logging those deferrals is valuable because a pattern of deferrals on operational questions, as opposed to commercial ones, signals that the answer may involve custom development or configuration work outside the base deployment. The number and nature of deferrals is itself evaluation evidence.
A Fictional Scenario: Managing a Transfer When the Subject Is Sensitive
Consider a scenario distinct from a billing dispute. A fictional account holder contacts a business in the healthcare administration sector. They are calling about an appointment that was changed without their knowledge, and they have already made travel arrangements they cannot recover. The AI agent correctly identifies the appointment change in the record system and confirms it. The account holder's tone shifts; they state that the change causes them a practical hardship.
This scenario is chosen deliberately because it involves no fraud risk, no regulatory decision and no complex technical integration, yet it creates an immediate question about who should speak next and what that person should know. The AI has confirmed a fact. It has not assessed whether the business bears any responsibility, whether a remedy is available or whether the account holder needs to speak with someone who can make a discretionary decision. A routing rule that sends all escalations to a general queue treats this conversation the same as a password reset that failed three times. Those are not equivalent situations.
In this scenario, the decision record entry would note: the AI correctly retrieved appointment data; the account holder indicated hardship; the escalation trigger was identified; the transfer was initiated. The open question is what the receiving agent found when they accepted the conversation. Did the record indicate hardship explicitly, or did the agent receive only a transcript? If the agent read the transcript, how long did that take, and did they begin the conversation with that context active or did they start from a greeting?
Observe also what the agent could not see. Could they see what the AI said about what would happen next? If the AI said a specialist would call back, and the agent was not a specialist, the agent is now managing a customer expectation that may not be within their authority to fulfil. That is a staffing design problem surfaced by a specific test case, and it is the kind of problem that a controlled evaluation exercise can reveal before it affects real customers.
For sensitive contact types, consider whether the handoff record should carry a flag distinguishing the customer's emotional state or the nature of their hardship from the factual content of their request. An agent who knows in advance that the customer is distressed can adjust their opening before the customer has to re-explain why. That adjustment may be within the configuration scope of either platform or may require custom implementation; the demonstration is the point at which to ask.
Questions That Change a Purchase Decision
Some evaluation questions are clarifying but not decisive; others genuinely change which option makes more sense for a specific operation. The following questions fall into the second category, and the reasons they are decisive rather than merely interesting are explained alongside each one.
Who owns the configuration of routing rules, and what does changing a rule require? This question matters because operational needs change after go-live, sometimes quickly. If updating a routing threshold requires a vendor support ticket or a development sprint, your operation's ability to respond to staffing changes or new contact types is limited in ways that will not appear in an initial demonstration. Ask for the change process by name, the typical elapsed time and who has authority to approve it.
How does the system behave when a connected data source is unavailable? The demonstration environment is likely to have all integrations functioning. Ask specifically what happens if the CRM or the ticketing system returns an error or a timeout during a live conversation. Does the AI agent inform the customer that it cannot retrieve information? Does it route to a human? Does it attempt a partial response? The answer determines whether a downstream system failure creates a dignified handoff or a confused customer experience, and it affects how your technical team will prioritise uptime monitoring for those connected systems.
What happens to conversations that begin on one channel and continue on another? A customer may start a query in a chat session, abandon it, and call in twenty minutes later. If those two interactions are treated as independent by the system, the human agent in the second interaction has no view of what was attempted in the first. That is not a hypothetical edge case for operations with multiple contact channels; it is a routine occurrence. Ask whether the proposed configuration links interactions by customer identity across channels, and if so, what the customer identity resolution logic is. The answer will tell you whether channel-crossing is a current feature in the quoted scope or a future capability.
What does the audit trail look like for a conversation that was handled entirely by the AI? When no human was involved, there may still be a need to review what was said, what was promised and what action was taken. Customer complaints, quality reviews and staff training all benefit from a complete and retrievable record. Ask to see a sample of a fully automated conversation record after the session has closed. Evaluate whether it contains enough information to reconstruct the interaction without access to a live playback.
How is a mistake by the AI agent corrected once the customer has left? If the AI gave incorrect information and the customer ended the conversation before a human intervened, what process exists to identify that conversation, contact the customer and correct the record? This is an ownership and process question, not a technical one. The platform may log the conversation; the question is whether your operation has a defined workflow for reviewing flagged conversations and acting on them. If that workflow does not exist before go-live, it needs to be designed as part of the implementation rather than left to emerge from experience.
Related guides
- Intercom Fin Voice vs Chat: Choose by the Customer Request
- Bland vs Retell Transfers: Escalation and Conversation Context
Comparing business systems? Explore Sysevo AI voice agents or book a Sysevo demo against the same requirements. This is an independent Sysevo editorial guide based on the linked vendor documentation, reviewed 2 November 2026. Examples are illustrative; no hands-on vendor test or guaranteed result is claimed. Sysevo publishes this guide and sells its own software.
For current Sysevo subscriptions and usage options, compare plans and pricing.



